Keeping a guestbook spam free isn’t easy
Saturday, December 30th, 2006I needed a new guestbook a few months ago, for a website I created. With my background, I of course knew how bad it could get, so I wanted to reduce the amount of moderating I needed to do. First I chose a guestbook that was created by someone who understood spam. He claimed it would kill spam effectively before it could even be posted.
Yeah, I’ve noticed an AOL member trying several times before her post got through…
But I also figured that if the guestbook couldn’t be found in Google, it wouldn’t be spammed. So I used robots.txt and even put nofollow on links to it. Problem was, I had forgotten about one or two, that didn’t have nofollow on them. Consequently, the link shows up in Google, without a blurb or cache. But it’s still named “guestbook”.
So I get the occasional spammy comment.
I have an idea for Googlebot (Matt, are you listening?):
If the site the document is on has ONLY nofollow links to it, you should not count links coming from OUTSIDE the same domain as an OK to display the link in Google. If the site ITSELF means for it to stay outside of Google, that should count as a NO! We can NOT police every link from outside. Granted, this time I was the one who made the error (put a link on a forum and on another site I owned. Both errors have been fixed now), but I’m sure you can see the potential for mischief here?